Thursday, October 15, 2009

Tonight I feel flustered. I've been having some difficulties with a particular ESL student and just read an email from her that basically told me she hates my class, my class assignments don't improve her English, and that she thinks I do my best to make the Korean students crazy. I promptly directed a feisty reply telling her exactly what I thought of her bad attitude and rudeness (don't worry, it was direct, but still polite). I know everything I said was perfectly justified; she's the one with the problem, not me. And I know that not all of my students are going to love everything I do in my class. Or that they're not all going to love me. I know these things. But it's just so disheartening when I put my best ideas and best effort forth, and someone, or worse, several someones, hate them. In my mind it means they hate me. And I should be ok with that, but apparently my tough "rhino skin," as my mom always called it, hasn't really grown in yet. I'm too sensitive for my own good.

So after an episode like tonight, all of my ambitious and creative ideas are beat down into submission, and I think maybe it would be better to just stick to the books. Why try doing anything interesting if everyone is going to hate it (ie hate me). I now feel flustered and upset and anxious and generally in turmoil. And I hate that almost more than I hate when people hate me.

8 comments:

Kristi said...

That would be frustrating. But just try and remember back to classes you didnt particularly love. Maybe the chick is just upset because she sucks at english all around and wants to blame it on someone and not herself for maybe not working her hardest. So I wouldnt take what she said as and reflection on your teaching abilities, or especially YOU. Because really, who cares what some stupid girl thinks about your class. You know you are a good teacher and i am sure there are many more students who LIKE you and appreciate the way you teach than not. So try not to let it get to you. :)

Caroline said...

What I have found is that you cannot please all students. Each student learns in their own way, and you cannot provide that for everyone. If the majority of your students are learning, you are doing well.

I have an idea for you about your Korean students, I will talk to you about it later. Different cultures expect different things.

M said...

Oh friend, I'm sorry. I think most (sane) teachers want to their class(es) to be enjoyed by students. It seems like, for the most part, you and your teaching methods are well-liked.

You're right - she's the one with the problem, not you. Keep on being ambitious and creative!

Receli said...

oh... wouldn't teaching be great if students didn't get in the way? jk.

After my first semester at BYU I got a really awful teacher rating from one of my students. I totally cried and was depressed about it! It is so hard to not be emotionally affected about your teaching because you are doing so much to help your students.

The more I learn in my ESL teaching methodology class, the more I realize that there isn't a perfect teacher or teaching method. Just a whole lot of people trying to be good teachers. And you are definitely in that category! I think you are awesome! :)

Lindsey said...

How many students do you have? Around 100 maybe??? Just think 99 of them love you or at least are not complaining. If this was a test you would get a 99%. That is pretty darn good. You can't please everyone. Just remember that 99% of your students are pleased.

Anonymous said...

Fauite says:


Yea I know, I like everyone to like me too. But I know they won't. Not all my staff will like me. Not everyone thought I was the best bishop in the world when I held that calling. I remember agonizing over that for about a year or two. Then I realized I had to just be me, love everyone best I could and do my job. If someone did not like it oh well.

So, remember, most your students like you. I think being direct but polite to the one who has an issue is appropriate. But do your thing and if she does not do well give her an F. You control not her.

Zillah said...

:(

Rachsticle said...

It is not you. It's her.