Thursday, June 5, 2008

but i deserve it

No, you don't. You really really don't.

So this morning, T-rav sent me a link to an article in the Deseret News and Salt Lake Tribune about an Iraqi guy who recently arrived in the US as a refugee. He has quite the tragic story: he worked as an interpreter for the Army, hired through the independent contracting company by the name of L3, and somehow lost both of his legs while serving. He claims his medical treatment from L3 was not fantastic, and the prosthetic legs he was given are too heavy and painful for him to use. But luckily, he was granted refugee status by the US (as he would most likely be killed if he returned to his hometown) and was shipped over here for a new life. Unluckily, the airline he flew on to the US managed to destroy his motorized wheelchair on the flight, and he hasn't yet been given a new one (he does have a hand-operated chair); he was only greeted at the airport by a Somali guy who had a funny accent; his apartment is tiny and by the freeway; he's only been given "normal" refugee status...etc, etc.

Now, this is all really terrible. Because of the service this man provided his country and our own, he can no longer live in safety in Iraq.

However...that does not mean that the US owes him. He worked as a private contractor who understood the risks of his job. I'm sure he was paid much more than he ever would have made at a regular job. Yes, we should be grateful for what he's done, but does that mean that we need to shower all glory, laud, and honor upon him? Does he deserve a brand new life handed to him on a silver platter?

NO.

This attitude is something that I think has become more and more pervasive in our society these days. Everyone thinks that the government owes them this and that because, well, I work hard and should be rewarded, right?

But what I think is even more interesting to watch is how different cultures view entitlement. Take two groups of refugees that T-rav works with: Iraqis and Burmese. Both have fled their countries because of war and unrest. Both are lucky to have been given a new life in the US. The Burmese have often been born and raised in refugee camps. When they get to the US, they are grateful and gracious for all the resettlement agency does for them. They rarely ask for extras, but are usually glad simply to have a chance to start over. On the other had, the Iraqis have often been living in Jordan or Syria before they arrive in the US. Some of them are educated, some of them are not. Many of them come from middle or upper class Iraq and had homes, jobs, and cars before they left. But when they get to the US, many (not all-remember, these are just generalizations) of them are disappointed and even resentful of the things they don't have. They ask why they don't have a TV, where is their computer, why their apartment is so small and simple, why they don't get a new car, why haven't they gotten their living stipend yet, why it isn't more, etc., etc.

I don't know if these differences are in part because one group had nothing in a refugee camp and one group had a little (or a lot) in another country. But either way, these people have nothing to complain about. They come with a group like the IRC or Catholic Community Services, who provide them with food, clothing, housing, jobs, English classes, integration into the US, support, immigration services (green cards, citizenship, etc), Medicaid, bus passes...and the list goes on. These same refugees also fail to notice that many of the people who work at the resettlement agencies and hear the constant barrage of demands are often over-educated, underpaid, and could easily get a much more lucrative job at a for-profit company.

The good news is that not everyone acts like this. There are plenty of stories of people who truly appreciate the chance they've been given at a new life. But those who haven't managed to learn to be grateful, I have 1 thing to say to you:

Life doesn't owe you anything.

5 comments:

Kristi said...

Thats really depressing that his wheel chair got beat up by the airlines. Will THEY at least replace it? They should. They better. He really does deserve a new wheel chair.

I don't really know what to say about this post. I feel bad for refugees ... that I will say. Can you imagine? :S That would be horrible- being OBLIGATED to leave your country so you don't die. Sad. :(

Kristi said...

I posted a new post. You should read it. Its quite disturbing. Actually, EVERYONE should read it...........

ego non said...

You would make a rather lovely libertarian. I agree with much of what you said. If you believe in the divine inspiration of the Declaration of Independence, a person's rights are 1)life 2)liberty and 3)the pursuit of happiness. It doesn't say housing, health care, or even food, let alone TVs, cars, mansions, monthly stipend, etc; however, just because I believe these aren't rights doesn't mean I don't think they're not important or necessary (food, housing, health care) to life. And certainly we can never use the argument of rights vs non-rights to excuse heinous crimes, homelessness, starvation, etc. And even more certainly, we can never brush off those in need by thinking or saying they've created their own problems and it hasn't a thing to do with us. Conveniently for Mormons, if we read and live the scriptures correctly, we know that because we are followers of Christ and because we long to be like him and love like him, it is our duty and our desire to care for others according to our time, talents, and financial abilities (Mosiah 18:8-10; Ephesian 2:19; Mosiah 4:14-22). Of course, it's all very individual and personal. Some old ladies sew quilts and clothing for the humanitarian aid, some young folks join up with organizations like Peace Corps, some rich people donate money, some smart people teach skills (teaching English, teaching gardening and sanitation skills, etc; see http://www.kateandneil.com/283/youre-not-a-racist/ if you're interested). I think it's good and useful to feel bad for refugees and other people in need because it should spur us on to be helpful to them and to care about them.

ixoj said...

Oh, I do think it's very important to be helpful to those in need. One of the best times of my life thus far was the months I spent in Guatemala teaching English, gardening, and business, building roads, working in the orphanage, etc. I think it's the duty and privelege of people who are blessed with safe and secure lives to offer support and aid to those less fortunate. It's just the attitude of entitlement that I despise, especially when they're not grateful for what they've already been given and instead just ask for more, more, more.

ego non said...

Oh, I didn't mean to come off preachy and I know you do care about helping others whenever you can. I simply meant that service is a way to fill in the gaps of need, instead of entitlement programs. Which is indeed why I think you'd make a great libertarian :) And I agree, ingratitude is heinous.