Wednesday, August 6, 2008

I heart Palestine part 2

We are now going to jump from the late 40s to the late 60s, skipping over the war known as the War of Independence by the Israelis and Al Nakba (or catastrophe) by the Palestinians, and go straight to the Six Day War. I'm sure it had many causes, after 9 years of relative "peace," what it came down to was disputes over land and water (like always), as well as the haughty boasts of Arab prowess by Egyptian President Abdel Nasser.

So one day Arab guerrilla fighters crossed the Lebanese border and blew up the water pipes by the Sea of Galilee, Israel's main source of water. Might I add that Israel had diverted much of the Jordan River away from the Arab States (because, you know, they needed it more).
  • "Israeli jets had bombed Syrian waterworks in the Golan Heights, across from Galilee, so that Syria could not diver those same waters. When Israelis moved into the demilitarized zones of the Golan [Heights] to plow disputed land, they drew Syrian fire, which in turn brought swift Israeli response." (p.125, The Lemon Tree)
Israel also claimed they needed to go to war because of the 100,000 Egyptian troops massing in the Sinai (American and British intelligence suggested closer to 50,000). Israel repeatedly exaggerated the state of things in Palestine, perhaps to influence the US or gain more support from Western Nations (which worked quite well). The CIA was quite sure that Egypt had no intention of going to war and were not planning to invade Israel. Even Israel's Minister of Defense would later admit that he never believed that Egypt wanted war.

But on June 5, 1967, the Israeli army made a preemtive strike against the Arabs and proceeded to seriously defeat the Egyptians, Syrians, and Jordanians, which wasn't enough- they also went into Palestinian territories and began a 40 year occupation of Palestinian land (the West Bank and Gaza), contrary to the UN Resolution 242 which mandated a withdrawal of Israeli armed forces from the occupied territories. Which they refused to do. And still do.

Eventually, the PLO was formed as the voice of Palestine, since they were not allowed to have any government of their own. Palestinian children are born and raised with the idea that they have been driven from their homes and deserve to get them back. Or at least should have their own state in the West Bank and Gaza.

And we all know all about suicide bombings and Israeli retaliation. Maybe you don't know that the Israelis imprisoned and tortured Palestinian prisoners who may or may not have been guilty of "terrorist" acts (meaning anything that went against Israeli laws- obviously if they were alive, they weren't suicide bombers). Or that, in the beginning, Israel was just as likely to bomb residential areas as the Palestinians. Or that, although the Palestinians are not very flexible on their demands for land and freedom, the Israelis are not very flexible on what they will offer the people whose land they stole (or stole back, if you prefer to live by Biblical Law).

Obviously, there is no easy solution. If I were in charge of the world, I would give the angry Arabs their own state, consisting of East Jerusalem, the West Bank, Gaza, and part of the Golan Heights. And then I would tell them to get over the fact that they don't have all of Palestine. And I would tell the Israelis to give up some of their land and point out that they have treated the Arabs the way they wished to have never been treated (mems how no one liked that people were driving Jews out at gun point and then they turned around and did the same thing?).

Anyway. If you think this is interesting, you should read a lovely book called The Lemon Tree, a story that follows both a Jewish and Palestinian family through all the drama of the pats 75 years. Another good one is In Search of Fatima. If any of you have any suggestions of other good Israel-Palestine books, I would love suggestions!

7 comments:

Marlo said...

Oh man, I loved this book. It got a little deep near the last third, but it was so, so interesting. And I agree with all the things you said in your last post Kelly. By the end of the book, I was so mad at the Jews.....why are they so crazy? Yes, the Palestinians are crazy too, but I would be too after all they went through. I just can never understand how the Israelis did all that they did RIGHT after the Holocaust. It's like they learned nothing, and in fact they unlearned things they knew before. Anyway, I wish more people knew a lot more about the conflict, instead of just knowing what all the pro-Israeli American newspapers and reporters, etc have had to say about this. And American history teachers for that matter. Well, that's about it. Sorry, but I get a little bit excited about this topic as well.

Unknown said...

Didn't the Zionist movement start well before the Holocaust? Isn't that the true cause of Israel's crazy actions? I don't know much about it - I'm asking.

I am, however, reading a book entitled Indian Wars, which gives some clear suggestions on how to force an indigenous population into submissiveness on special lands we call 'reservations.' If the Jews truly wanted to make the Palestinians submit, it wouldn't be hard - just cruel.

ixoj said...

Ryry- Yes, the Zionist movement started in the 1800s with Herzl (as mentioned in my previous post), but really began to catch on in the early 1900s. And yes, Zionism did greatly contribute to the Jews' migration to Israel, but that still doesn't mean they should displace another people.

Anonymous said...

ixoj wrote:

Obviously, there is no easy solution. If I were in charge of the world, I would give the angry Arabs their own state, consisting of East Jerusalem, the West Bank, Gaza, and part of the Golan Heights. And then I would tell them to get over the fact that they don't have all of Palestine. And I would tell the Israelis to give up some of their land and point out that they have treated the Arabs the way they wished to have never been treated (mems how no one liked that people were driving Jews out at gun point and then they turned around and did the same thing?).



Fautie says:

I think this is a reasonable proposal. I personally think that the Palestinians deserve their own state and a place to live. But there was as start to this with Gaza and they still blow up themselves to take out Israelis. This is what makes me wonder if they are really interested in a peaceful solution.

Long held traditions and religious views and perceived rights die hard. I am not holding my breath that things will settle down there in my life or yours. And it will only heat up if the nut jobs in Iran continue to threaten Israel. Like it or not Israel take little garbage from hostile nations. Don't be surprises when they pull an air strike on Iran's nuclear facilities.

Fauite

Anonymous said...

I am curious. For all you Bible believers...what do you think about the Old Testament stories where God led Israel out of Egypt then told them to take Canaan for their own and wipe out all its inhabitants?

Fautie

ixoj said...

I think that the world used to run by what the Bible said...and now it doesn't. So what may have been ok in ancient times obviously no longer is.

Marlo said...

Ah Kelly, you always make me laugh. Are you ready for your next read? Jamieson is just finishing Shake Hands With the Devil by Romeo Dellaire. It is about the genocide in Rwanda. Dellaire was the UN peacekeeping forces general there. I think I will pass on this one, but thought I would pass it along to you, in case you are up for more exciting reading.

As for the Old Testament, I might feel differently about the conflict if God indeed did tell the Jews of today to wipe out the Palestinians in the way that they have. But since He didn't, and Ariel Sharon and others did, I think we can safely follow the laws that exist now, not Biblical laws.

Additionally, Haredi Jews don't believe in Zionism and don't believe in taking over Israel because they believe political independence should not come from man, but from God. So not even all the Jews/Israelis/whomever agree about the conflict. I do however, agree that the Palestinians have now gone way overboard and probably nothing will be changed until the Lord returns again, but I still pick the Palestinians over the Israelis. Why, oh why do I get so excited about this?